by John Stoltenberg

DC site-specific theater of resistance reached a new height last night—also a new low—as Alliance for New Music-Theatre’s arresting staging of Vaclav Havel’s Protest became the first play performed before a live audience in the District’s “new Subterranean Arts & Cultural Center,” the abandoned trolley roundabout now redone as Dupont Underground.

The convergence of place, play, performance, and present political predicament was almost too perfect.

Drew Valins (Vanek) and David Millstone (Stanek) in Protest at Alliance for New Music-Theatre. Courtesy of Alliance for New Music-Theatre.

The venue, Dupont Underground, deserves a visit in its own right and its own review. One enters down a stairway and arrives in a vast, arcing, echoing chamber, with murals on the outer wall and trolley tracks embedded underfoot. It was built for a streetcar system that was superseded by cars and buses after World War II, and during the Cold War was a bunker stocked with provisions in the event of a nuclear bomb.

Dupont Underground entrance and interior and staging for Protest. Photographs by John Stoltenberg for DCMetroTheaterArts.

The architectural drama that now imbues the space—and makes you go “Wow, something amazing could happen here”—compares to that of other theaters built for that purpose on massive budgets. The fact this is a “found” civic space reclaimed for live performance gives it a populist vibe that money can’t buy. Plus, the very location (which could not be more public-transportation accessible) invokes the history of political resistance in the city that has centered around the Dupont Circle fountain.

“Every protest that has ever been here has been upstairs,” said Artistic Director Susan Galbraith in her introductory remarks on opening night.

Alliance for New Music-Theatre is a company “committed to engage audiences changing the conversation through the arts [italics theirs].” This production of Protest is its first as Dupont Underground’s theater in residence. The once-banned play has been smartly directed by Galbraith and designed by Joey Wade (set, lights, and projections) to suggest the living rooms in which the play was first performed privately to circumvent state censure. The simple makeshift look is apt and compelling: Two chairs and a table on a carpet on a raised platform backed by a plain white wall. LED lights behind the audience wash the stage in shifting hues and brightness with no discernible reason except to convey an uncanny context of uncertainty, instability, flux, and possible power outage.

The production began as a commission by the Embassy of the Czech Republic and was performed to mark Havel’s 80th birthday at, among other places, the President Woodrow Wilson House. The set of Protest now at Dupont Underground has on its side walls projected photographs of that interior, including a portrait of First Lady Elizabeth Wilson.

David Millstone (Stanek) and Drew alins (Vanek) in Protest at Alliance for New Music-Theatre. Courtesy of Alliance for New Music-Theatre.

The character whose home this is, Stanek (David Millstone), might well be that grandly domiciled. Stanek once lived a politically fringy life but now, having made it big as a television writer, lives comfortably well off, keeps his radical past at a remove, and enjoys gardening and fine brandy. He could easily be pegged a bourgie sell-out except he finds himself in a situation that he knows needs an activist assist. His daughter’s boyfriend, a pop star, has been imprisoned by the authorities. In hopes of mounting a petition campaign to free the young man, Stanek has invited his still-dissident longtime friend Vanek (Drew Valins), to come for a visit. Vanek was once himself a political prisoner. Stanek needs his political cred but doesn’t want to take any risk of his own. Vanek turns the tables and challenges Stanek himself to sign the petition. Will he or won’t he? Dare he or daren’t he? Vanek’s and Stanek’s disagreement about political tactics drives the drama, and Millstone and Valins play out their differences with probing panache.

With witty direction from Galbraith, Millstone leads Valins in seeming to connive leaning over the parlor table, then hilariously crawling under it. Each in turn plays at times to the audience with an entertaining earnestness, as if expecting allies for their views. Indeed there emerges a cleverly competitive subtext, an invitation to join Team Vanek or Team Stanek.

Drew Valins (Vanek) and David Millstone (Stanek) in Protest at Alliance for New Music-Theatre. Courtesy of Alliance for New Music-Theatre.

The playwright has given Stanek most of the lines, and Millstone plays them to the hilt, sometimes shouting them resoundingly into the cavernous tunnel. His performance is fantastically frenetic. Vanek has far fewer lines, and Valins’s delivery is more deliberate, more quietly certain, less emotionally ostentatious. Clearly the audience Havel wrote for would have known what Vanek was thinking because they like Havel were like Vanek, so the character had less need to explain himself. The expansive character of Stanek, however, is where the play becomes a revelation.

Staneck’s debate within himself, articulated with textual precision, becomes an enthralling inquiry into conscience, courage, and complicity. Stanek has a long final monologue in which he weighs the consequences of signing or declining to sign the petition that would be the public protest of the play’s title. As scathingly scripted by Havel and here performed magnificently by Millstone, that speech is a showstopping knockout, a moral-intellectual mind-blower. That it speaks with eerie specificity to current resistance to #resistance is the best possible reason to see this show.

Note that Dupont Underground is accessible only by a stairway only partially equipped with handrails and has no restrooms, although patrons may use facilities in the lobby of the Dupont Hotel across the street.

Running Time: One hour 5 minutes, with no intermission.

Protest plays through May 21, 2017, at Alliance for New Music-Theatre performing at Dupont Underground (public entrance is at 1500 19th Street NW, Washington, DC, on north side of Dupont Circle next to Starbucks and across from Dupont Hotel). Tickets may be purchased online.


‘Protest’ at Ambassador Theater at Flashpoint, by Justin Schneider